It’s always a good idea to diversify investments as a hedge against an uncertain future. Several visitors wrote in and asked should I invest in chattels now? Let’s review the implications of chattels held purely for investment in England. Then you can use this as input to an informed investment decision.
Not All Chattels Make Wise Investments
Chattels are anything we can move around and touch. This definition includes everyday objects like furniture and phones. However, chattels also include collectible items like heirlooms, paintings, and jewellery that may accumulate in value.
English law treats personal and investment chattels differently. There are knock-on differences if you invest. You need to know the implications for capital gains tax, as well as inheritance and probate. And how your executor or adviser might value and distribute your estate, before you decide should I invest in chattels.
When Is a Chattel a Chattel in England?
In principle, a chattel is anything you can move and touch. But having said that, English statutes and tax laws do introduce exclusions. The Inheritance and Trustees’ Powers Act of 2014, for example, excludes the following from personal chattels:
- Money, securities, and property held solely as an investment or used in a business.
- Any item held purely to make money as an investment, rather than for personal use.
These exclusions affect how the UK government regulates and taxes investment chattels in deceased estates. Please stay with us a while, as we help you decide whether to include chattels in your portfolio.
Intention Matters With Investment Chattels
An executor of a deceased estate must distinguish between personal and investment chattels, because the law treats them differently:
- They may distribute personal chattels per the will, or the letter of intentions.
- However they must treat any investment chattels as financial investments.
This distinction may affect the distribution of assets under the will, or by value under intestacy rules. Executors often contact us for advice where the deceased invested in chattels and other valuable items.
We may then review purchase records, sale listings, consignment history, storage, and catalogue evidence to help determine the deceased’s intentions when acquiring the asset(s).
Capital Gains Tax and Wasting Chattels
This is one of your most important considerations, when deciding should I invest in chattels or salt my money away elsewhere. This is because there are actually two classes of chattels, and the capital gains tax office treats them differently:
- ‘Wasting’ chattels’ have a predictable life of 50 years or less, and are generally capital gains tax exempt.
- Whereas ‘non wasting chattels’ have a predictable life of over 50 years, and there may be taxable gains when sold.
If a non-wasting chattel was held as an investment, then the taxable gains rule applies. This is why we strongly recommend maintaining a record of investment intentions.
Valuing Chattel Investments at Death
We now turn to the important topic of calculating the value of investment chattels, for probate and tax.This information may help you decide how much you should invest in chattels in the first place.
HMRC may require specialist, professional market valuations for high value items. Investment chattels may for example include jewellery, art, collections, wine, coins, and more.
The tax office also expects that investment collections are underpinned by documents such as invoices, correspondence, and consignment or sale history. Having clear documentary evidence avoids disputes, and reduces the risk of HMRC or beneficiaries challenging a classification or valuation.
Tips To Help You Navigate Chattel Law
- Make your intentions clear in writing, if you buy an item as an investment.
- Keep invoices, catalogue descriptions, storage agreements and correspondence.
- A short written note concerning the purpose of the investment can prevent later disputes.
- Maintain separate written records of personal-use items and investment chattels.
- Obtain specialist valuations for high-value or unusual items from professional valuers.
- HMRC often relies on these documents for significant collections, or single items.
We provide the information in this article as a general introduction for non-legal investors. Consequently,we recommend you ask a tax or probate specialist if anything is borderline or uncertain.
English law examines the facts and purposes of chattel investments at the time of acquisition and death. We quite frequently come across ambiguous cases, for example jewellery sometimes used, but stored for appreciation at other times.
Wrapping Up and Moving Forward
The case for whether a chattel is ‘personal’ or ‘held purely for investment’ is often unclear, and becomes a question of purpose and evidence. This difference matters. It changes how items feature in probate, how beneficiaries may receive them, and how tax rules may apply.
Good record-keeping, early valuation of high-value items, and professional advice where the purpose is unclear, will often avoid disputes and unexpected tax bills at emotional moments after the death of a loved one.
Avery Associates is at hand to assist you with professional chattel and fixed property valuations, that should meet the needs of the HMRC tax office and heirs. Please contact us when convenient, if you feel we can assist with a professional valuation.
More Information
