Avery Associates

House Clearance & Probate Valuation Services


  • HOME
  • HOUSE CLEARANCE
    • Probate House Clearance
    • House Clearance
    • FAQ
    • Hoarder House Clearance
    • Garden Clearance
    • Charity Donations
    • Recycling
    • House Clearance Gallery
    • Our Locations
  • PROBATE VALUATIONS
    • PROBATE HELP
      • Probate Valuation Guide Fees & Advice
      • Probate House Clearance
      • Executor Assistance
      • Solicitor Assistance
      • Our Locations
    • Probate Valuation Explained
    • RICS Property Valuation
    • Classic Cars
    • Jewellery
    • Coins
    • Books
    • Stamps
    • Vintage Toys
    • Records
  • REVIEWS
  • NEWS
  • ABOUT
  • CONTACT

Can a Deathbed Gift Override the Rules of Intestacy?

November 16, 2019 By Richard Farrell

Picture the scene of a person receiving their last rites, as physicians confirm they will pass away soon. Relatives gather around the deathbed paying their last respects. A stranger enters, rushes forward, and whispers something.

The dying person’s eyes open and they sit up and say, “Ah yes, it’s so good to see you again. Now you are back I want you to have my stamp collection … I remember how you admired it.” Then they fall back with a smile on their face, gone forever.

The people around the bed are aghast, especially the stamp-collecting nephew. Who can this person be? Are they a secret lover or a special friend from the past? The wannabe inheritors argue even though they have not seen the will.

Is the Deathbed Gift of the Stamp Collection Valid?

Yes, it can override a will if meets a narrow set of criteria. A causa mortis – or donation mortis causa – as the law calls it is a future gift on the basis on an immediately pending death. Hence the giver must die shortly afterwards from whatever made them believe they were about to die.

A deathbed gift can therefore only overrule intestacy (or a will) when the giver is in a terminal state and dies shortly afterwards. Deathbed gifts are regularly disputed, for example in the following case:

Steven Keeling and the Deathbed Gift of Ellen Exler

Steven Keeling aged 84 regularly visited his widowed older sister Ellen Exler as her death neared. Then she died without a will aged 91 as a widower without children, meaning her surviving brothers would share her estate.

The widow’s estate was worth close to a million pounds. Her only other brother Frank had dementia. Steven Keeling applied for and received letters of administration. This meant he had the power to share his sister’s estate equally between himself and his brother Frank.

However, Steven Keeling announced his sister had given him the deeds and the keys to her property after an earlier heart attack. According to him, Ellen had said she wanted him and his wife to have the house. Steven Keeling transferred to property accordingly and rented it out.

But Brother Frank’s Family Did Not Agree

The other interested parties lodged a challenge. This was because Ellen had told her carers she did not want Steven Keeling and his wife to “get their hand on my money” according to Curtis Parkinson Solicitors. She had added, according to them “that they would never get my house over my dead body”.

However, a personal assessment was the clincher that convinced the Court. This “cast serious doubt” on Ellen’s capacity to manage her own affairs. Accordingly, Judge Charles Hollander QC handed down the following judgement:

Steven Keeling gave inconsistent evidence

His late sister survived the heart attack by six months

Therefore she did not have good reason to expect imminent death

Thus any “contemplated death” did not occur and so the gift lapsed

The Essence of Judge Charles Hollander’s Decision

A deathbed gift can override a will or the rules of intestacy, only if the giver anticipated imminent death, the death occurred shortly afterwards for that reason, and the giver delivered the item or transferred ownership. These conditions did not apply in Ellen Exler’s case, and hence the brothers shared the estate.

Related

Filed Under: Probate Valuation Tagged With: Can a Deathbed Gift Override the Rules of Intestacy?, donation mortis causa, Is the Deathbed Gift of the Stamp Collection Valid?, probate valuation, rules of intestacy, Steven Keeling and the Deathbed Gift of Ellen Exler

Our House Clearance Services

We provide a full house clearance and property management solution:

  • We clear hoarded houses, regardless how big or how cluttered
  • We clear all types and sizes of property, irrespective of location, or access is restricted or where parking is difficult or not available.
  • We can help avoid water damage by draining the central heating system.
  • We can secure the property and change the locks.
  • We can reinstate the gardens and maintain them whilst the property is empty.
  • We can provide 24 hour security to eliminate the risk of squatting or unlawful occupation.

As well normal house clearances we specialise in clutter clearance and we can clear a hoarded house which may contain years of accumulated possessions, or which have abnormal amounts of general household items, sometimes as a result of compulsive hoarding syndrome.

Equally we can help to clear a property where the occupants were previously unwell and unable to care for themselves or their property which sometimes results in insanitary, dangerous or just plain unpleasant conditions.

More info

About Richard Farrell

What We Do

Get A Quick Quote

Client Reviews

Jenny Schon
Dec 3, 2021
 by Jenny Schon on Avery Associates
Well done

This truly is a 'one stop shop' for all things relating to Probate valuations and clearance. Jeffrey is a 'facilitator' and full marks to him for finding... Read More

Kevin Anderson
Oct 26, 2021
 by Kevin Anderson on Avery Associates
Fantastic and Reliable

Our aunt was a recluse and hoarder. She died leaving two properties in London that were dilapidated and completely hoarded. Unfortunately, because everything... Read More

It was a pleasure to assist Kevin

T. Hackett
Aug 26, 2021
 by T. Hackett on Avery Associates
1st Class Service

Avery Associates Appraisal I have just moved house after almost 30 years of occupation. My initial choice of movers, Pickfords, decided at the last... Read More

Page 1 of 44:
«
 
‹
 
1
2
3
›
 
»
 

Share, Email or Print

Looking For Something?

Our Latest News & Advice

  • Thought I Had Seen Everything Until I Visited Walsall
  • How to Apply for Probate in England and Wales
  • England’s Ambitious Waste Plan by Jeffrey Avery


Avery Associates
291 Mitcham Rd
Tooting SW179JQ

Tel: 0800 567 7769 or 0208 640 0044

Services provided throughout London and the Home Counties. View our clearance case studies.


Website Terms | Privacy Policy | Sitemap | Copyright © 2005-2018 Avery Associates
Website Development by Avara Web Media